Ladies ride the range in fun but unlikely Western
BAD GIRLSDirected by Jonathan Kaplan.
Screenplay by Ken Friedman and Yolande Finch.
Starring Madeleine Stowe, Mary Stuart Masterson, Andie MacDowell, and Drew Barrymore.
By Gretchen Koot
Staff Reporter
In this movie, the gunslinging protagonists are girls.
The movie opens with the women all working as whores in a saloon in Echo City, Colorado. For the first few minutes, things seem peaceful enough with the women giggling and the men hollering and laughing good naturedly while a congregation of puritans marches outside, denouncing the saloon as a den of iniquity.
Alas, this vision of tranquillity does not last long. A drunken colonel chases Anita (Mary Stuart Masterson) from one of the rooms, demanding a birthday kiss. He becomes violent when she resists. Cody, a straight-shooting, tough-talking woman played by Madeliene Stowe demands that the colonel behave himself. He replies by shooting at her, and she shoots back, killing him. Immediately, the town's people begin screaming that "The whore shot the colonel," and we can see that she isn't about to be informed of her right to an attorney. In the following scene, we see a noose thrown over a town sign which announces, "Welcome to Echo City, Colorado's friendliest town."
Luckily for Cody, her friends aren't about to let her be hung. They rescue her and gallop off to begin their adventures and the main part of the movie, which involves trying to retrieve Cody's savings first from a bank and then from some scuzzy bad guys.
The worst part of the movie was the gratuitous bashing of religion early in the film. Echo City's minister rants on about the whore of Babylon and women with figurative scorpions between their legs. Unfortunately, this cardboard stereotype of the religious as sexually obsessed and cruel seems to have become an mainstay of modern Hollywood pictures. During Cody's escape, the minister is thrown into the dirt, and there is split second shot of a horse's hoof trodding on his bible. Thankfully, that's the last we see of him or his type in the film.
The best part of the movie is the action, and there is a lot of it. Lily (Drew Barrymore) must stop a runaway wagon by leaping to it from her galloping palomino. It is a stock western scene, but I still couldn't restrain a gasp when Lily fell backwards with her head dangerously close to a speeding wagon wheel. Later, the girls must attempt a daring jail break when Eileen, played with wonderful humor by Andie MacDowell, falls from her horse and is held in a jail in Agua Dulce. Eileen's manipulative sweet talk to her endearingly naive jailer is at once tender and humorous.
There are a few scenes which show the unique frustrations of women in the old west, such as when Anita cannot claim the land she and her husband staked because her husband is dead and she is female. However, this theme of women's victimization is downplayed, and the characters don't spend much time bemoaning their second class status. This isn't a theme movie. It's just women playing cowboys, and most of the time they are having a good time doing it. They get to be the strong, adventurous heroes that usually only men are allowed to be.
Most of the film seems highly unrealistic but that fits the genre. For a more serious exploration of what women had to deal with in the old west, I'd recommend a movie called The Ballad of Little Joe. Of course, the constraints of realism made that movie much less fun and more disturbing to watch than this one. Bad Girls may not serve the same dramatic purpose, but all in all it's a fun way to spend an afternoon.


