Phish members join Dude of Life in hybrid concert
The Dude of Life
The Paradise.By John Jacobs
The Dude of Life played at the Paradise last Thursday. No, wait a minute -- Phish played at the Paradise last Thursday. Um, no, that's not quite right, either. ...
Actually, it was a hybrid beast of a band that took the stage that night. Phish drummer Jon Fishman was already on-stage as the Dude's drummer and it was rumored before the show that Phish guitarist Trey Anastasio would join them.
Those rumors turned out to be true. When Trey took the stage, the audience went wild with excitement. It was like a small hurricane of flannel, dotted with prep school caps and "Is it Live or is it Dead?" T-shirts.
The Dude's band and Trey played a few songs before they were joined by Phish bassist Mike Gordon, whose appearance took the crowd completely by surprise. The introductions were ideally spaced for optimal crowd reaction, and the crowd did react. The air tingled with energy and excitement. With three-quarters of Phish on-stage, the Dude of Life launched into "I Don't Care About Anybody But Myself."
Although Trey stayed for the whole set, Mike left after two or three numbers. His replacement, the Dude of Life's bassist, opted for more traditional baselines, but redeemed himself by singing the band's cover of "Respect" by Aretha Franklin.
The Dude himself was kind of a dork. With his top hat and his gold-trimmed red cape, he bore an uncanny resemblance to both Slash and the evil prince from The Princess Bride. Besides singing poorly, the Dude does not play any instruments. This means that he has absolutely nothing to do while the instrumentalists solo. Nothing, that is, except look more like a dork by nodding or shaking his head to the beat of the song.
Supposedly, at the Dude's concert in Northampton, he outdid himself by wearing stockings, a green dress, a top hat, and goggles. At that concert, he threw rubber sharks and a rubber pig into the crowd. The audience at the Paradise had to settle for one rubber chicken, which he taunted us with first.
The Dude's primary strength is purported to be as a lyricist. He wrote the words to "Dinner and a Movie" and "Fluffhead," both cuts from Phish's Junta album. However, the lyrics for "Dinner and a Movie" consist entirely of (no joke): "Let's go out to dinner and see a movie." At the Paradise, the Dude came out as lyrically insane. His songs betrayed a twisted sense of humor, not the kind of humor to bond to an audience with.
Because of Trey's presence, the Dude's backup band was hard to appraise. They couldn't seem to blend with Trey's guitar solos, and Trey seemed to have no desire to match their less jazzy style. The resultant lack of coherence left the music less satisfying than it could have been.
The Dude's guitarist was good, in spite of his penchant for Phish-like off-key solos. The keyboardist, however, was exceptionally bad. He forced the band to let him solo, then sounded horrible. The band actually cut his solo short and did not encourage him to solo again.
The set list included "Lucy in the Subway with Daffodils," "She's Bitchin' Again," and "Family Picture." The band also covered the Beatles' "Sexie Sadie" (which they performed very well), "Respect," Steppenwolf's "Livin' After Midnight (Rockin' till the Dawn)," and James Brown's "I Feel Good."
The show turned out to be pretty good, though there's no telling how it would have gone if the Dude of Life had had to stand on his own, without Trey Anastasio or Mike Gordon. On the other hand, the show with Trey and Mike could have been better with a little rehearsing.
If you're going to see the Dude of Life, see them where Phish won't let them fall flat, like Boston, or maybe Nectar's in Burlington.