The Tech - Snowy Online EditionMIT's oldest and largest
newspaper & the first
newspaper published
on the web
Boston Weather: 33.0°F | Light Snow Fog/Mist and Breezy

Showdown Over Future of Hong Hong Delated by Governor

By Rone Tempest
Los Angeles Times


A showdown between Britain and China over democratic electoral reforms here was averted -- or at least delayed -- as Gov. Chris Patten called Wednesday for continued negotiations before China assumes control of this British colony in 1997.

Patten, former chairman of the Conservative Party in Britain, enraged the Chinese government last October in his first policy speech as governor when he called for an increase in directly elected representatives on the Hong Kong Legislative Council.

Some supporters of democracy here hoped Patten would use the occasion of his annual address before the council Wednesday to announce his intention to go ahead with the reforms without China's approval.

But after a year in which he was the focus of venomous attacks by Chinese officials, who have described him as a "prostitute," the Hong Kong governor avoided a direct confrontation.

He said he hopes for a settlement before November, when he plans to travel to London to brief British Prime Minister John Major on the status of talks between the two governments.

Privately, however, officials said talks were at a dead end after 12 rounds, with little hope for resolution.

In his address Wednesday, Patten confirmed published reports that British negotiators have offered the Chinese two major compromises, in one case cutting democratic representation at a district level by two-thirds.

But he said the British have received no offers in return from the other side.

"Alas, we have still not succeeded in convincing Chinese officials that Hong Kong's extraordinarily modest aspirations for political development are legitimate," Patten said in his address, delivered in the boxy, wood-paneled chamber of the Victorian-era Legislative Council building, surrounded by the gleaming banks and office towers of the island's central district.

In 1990, Beijing said it would accept direct election of 20 of 60 members of the Legislative Council. The first direct elections were held in 1991 when 18 members were directly elected.

But Patten's reforms called for the election of the majority of the council's members in elections scheduled for 1995. Such a format would allow what Patten describes as a "through train," in which elected members would have two years of their terms remaining when China takes over.

Some critics, however, accuse the British of using Patten to make a last-minute grandstand play to avoid the impression that they are abandoning Hong Kong. Even some supporters of democratic reform join in this cynical view of the departing British.

"What Patten has offered is only a drop of democracy," said Emily Lau, an outspoken elected member of the council who supports Hong Kong independence from China. "Whatever the British are doing is to save face. I don't understand why it is that Patten has been lionized in the Western press as a champion of freedom and democracy."