The Tech - Online EditionMIT's oldest and largest
newspaper & the first
newspaper published
on the web
Boston Weather: 27.0°F | Partly Cloudy

Nixon Defense Secretaries Say U.S. Left POWs in Vietnam

By William J. Eaton
Los Angeles Times


Two former secretaries of defense under Richard M. Nixon testified Monday that the U.S. government believed in 1973 that many American fliers remained in enemy hands in Laos and were not returned with other prisoners at the end of the Vietnam War, despite Nixon's public assurances to the contrary.

"As of now, I can come to no other conclusion. (But) that does not mean there are any alive today," said former Secretary of Defense James R. Schlesinger, who also once served as head of the Central Intelligence Agency.

The sworn testimony by Schlesinger and Melvin R. Laird, Nixon's first Pentagon chief, marked the first time top-ranking members of the Nixon administration were questioned publicly about the fate of U.S. servicemen still listed as missing in action almost 20 years after the United States withdrew from Vietnam.

In effect, their testimony before the Senate Select Committee on POW-MIA Affairs corroborated earlier statements by Ross Perot, the Texas tycoon who has been deeply involved in POW-MIA activities since 1969. Perot told the Senate panel last month that the evidence was "overwhelming" that POWs were left behind after the Vietnam War ended.

The testimony also supports the judgment of many members of the Senate's special POW-MIA committee and is the most authoritative evidence so far of what was once an unthinkable conclusion -- that the American government essentially wrote off pending POW-MIA cases at the war's end in effort to close the book on the foreign policy disaster.

"I think it's quite extraordinary when two former secretaries of defense both give evidence documenting that they had information, or they believed personally, that people were alive and not accounted for in Operation Homecoming," said Sen. John Kerry, D-Mass., chairman of the Select Committee.

The defense chiefs' remarks are likely to escalate demands by servicemen's families that more be done to pressure the Vietnamese and other governments for an accounting of the fate of the missing.

The day's events set the stage for Tuesday's appearance by Henry A. Kissinger, who conducted secret talks with the North Vietnamese in Paris, on the terms he negotiated for release of the POWs and for a full accounting of hundreds of others declared missing.

Kissinger -- who served as national security adviser and secretary of state under Nixon -- was certain to be asked about documented discussions within the Nixon administration about using military force or strong diplomatic pressure on behalf of an estimated 350 Americans who were believed to be held by enemy forces after their planes were shot down over Laos.

Questioning by Kerry indicated that Kissinger would be asked whether those Americans believed to have been held in Laos were written off as expendable in an effort to cut short the bitter and politically divisive war.

Schlesinger, who said the Pentagon had been in contact with some of the downed fliers after they parachuted to safety, speculated that some of them may have been executed. Kerry said others may have been killed in combat on the ground or died of exposure in the jungle.

In his testimony, Laird, a former Wisconsin congressman who pushed for "Vietnamization" of the conflict so American troop levels could be reduced after 1969, said the Pentagon had solid information, such as letters or direct contacts, with about 20 American airmen who survived in Laos after their planes were shot down.

While he did not say how many prisoners he believed were not properly accounted for, Laird said he was disappointed by the list of 10 names that the Laotians released to U.S. negotiators through the North Vietnamese.

A memo to Kissinger from Secretary of Defense Elliott L. Richardson, dated March 28, 1973, said the Defense Intelligence Agency listed more than 350 Americans as missing or captured in Laos at the time the list was provided by the Laotians.

A day later, however, Nixon declared in a television address to the nation that as a result of the Paris peace talks, "All of our American POWs are on their way home."

Not long after, 527 POWs, mainly held by North Vietnam, did return in the dramatic "Operation Homecoming."

"I think it was unfortunate to be that positive," Laird said of Nixon's assertion that all POWs would be returned. "You can't be that positive when we had the kind of intelligence we had when I left."

Laird resigned as defense secretary in January 1973, but returned to the White House as a counselor to Nixon later that year. Schlesinger, who became defense secretary in July 1973 after a brief stint as head of the CIA, was asked if he felt any of those who were captured in Laos were still alive.

"I believe those prospects would be very slim," he said. "It's conceivable that one or two may have survived, or a handful."

Also appearing before the committee was Kissinger's former assistant, Alexander Haig, who was later a White House adviser to Nixon. Haig, combative and confrontational, strongly disagreed with the suggestion the administration knew Americans were left behind.

He said he did not believe the North Vietnamese produced a full accounting of U.S. prisoners, but he insisted he saw no evidence that living Americans had been left in captivity, and he strongly questioned the committee's motives in raising the issue now.

The committee also wants to investigate allegations that top Pentagon officials tried to hush up information about U.S. airmen held in Laos or other remote locations, as suggested by newly declassified documents made public by the panel.

A Defense Department report for the week ending April 7, 1973, for example, listed 80 U.S. military personnel as "current captured", although Pentagon officials a few days later declared there was no indication that any Americans remained in the former Indo China after the `Homecoming' exodus.