Editor’s Note: See our blog for a summary of The Tech’s coverage on Aaron Swartz.
Computer activist Aaron H. Swartz committed suicide in New York City yesterday, Jan. 11, according to his uncle, Michael Wolf, in a comment to The Tech. Swartz was 26.
“The tragic and heartbreaking information you received is, regrettably, true,” confirmed Swartz’ attorney, Elliot R. Peters of Kecker and Van Nest, in an email to The Tech.
Swartz was indicted in July 2011 by a federal grand jury for allegedly downloading millions of documents from JSTOR through the MIT network — using a laptop hidden in a basement network closet in MIT’s Building 16 — with the intent to distribute them. Swartz subsequently moved to Brooklyn, New York, where he then worked for Avaaz Foundation, a nonprofit “global web movement to bring people-powered politics to decision-making everywhere.” Swartz appeared in court on Sept. 24, 2012 and pleaded not guilty.
The accomplished Swartz co-authored the now widely-used RSS 1.0 specification at age 14, founded Infogami which later merged with the popular social news site reddit, and completed a fellowship at Harvard’s Ethics Center Lab on Institutional Corruption. In 2010, he founded DemandProgress.org, a “campaign against the Internet censorship bills SOPA/PIPA.”
I did not know you before reading this, Man, only thing I hope is that now you feel better than before.
If we knew each other, you could have asked for my help as a friend.
Maybe your departure will make some people realize how far we are from each other as persons..
Blame government? Too easy.
Blame our own ego which is tied to a pathological materialism, need for money, personal success, forgetting what has the biggest value in the world:
Human beeing. Persons. Persons with their difficulties, up and downs, moments of magnificient brightness... Persons which sometimes look lonely.
Our biggest guilt is we had this guy loose his "faith" in this world.
Bad people (in this case and many others, government) can destroy your life.
But the thing that is gonna make you loose all your hopes and say "bye bye" is seeing other people around being indifferent.
We need to be closer to each other.
If we notice someone having a bit of a stressful time, a strange situation, we need to talk to him/her, we need to show we are close to him/her as a human being, even if we do not know him/her. Anything but just don't walk over.
He/She just needs to be reassured that the world is still a nice place to be. And it is, because of us. Don't let them forget this.
If you notice someone in a bit of a difficult moment, talk to himher.
Don't let this happen again!
RIP IN LE PEACE sweet prince, your my hero.
https://aaronsw.jottit.com/howtoget
http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/sj/2011/07/24/aaron-swartz-v-united-states/
RIP, Aaron.
You won't be forgotten and all your efforts will be brought on for the same good causes that moved you. Thank you.
Our hearts are with you.
My deepest sympathies to his family,
from Twain: dream other dreams and better.
HOW PATHETIC/ how weak. ONCE AGAIN ANOTHER FOOL LETS THE GOV'T WIN. i have no respect for ANY HUMAN/
This piece of garbage was an embarrassment to ethics.
Aaron was the creator of webpy, my favourite python framework for web development.
From now on, every time I use this piece of software, I'll remember him with gratitude.
#17 Well said.
Rest in peace, bright light.
When will we TELL PUBLIC SERVANTS ENOUGH?
Who gives these creeps the right to act like PUBLIC TYRANTS, pursuing injustices and making people like AARON feel so terrible that he would take his own life?
Will we be ever prosecuting ANYONE for making him feel that way?
May G_D rest your soul SIR and may we heal by honoring your mission... Bringing CROWD decision making to those "C" students BABOONS in governments everywhere
Like a shooting star you shone brightly but all too briefly.
Shouldn't such an induction outrage everyone at MIT??? Isn't it part of our goals - as MIT community members - to create and distribute scientific knowledge to anyone?
The underlines pretty well the insanity of the current paid-access system to research articles. https://www.quora.com/Scientific-Research/To-what-extent-does-paid-access-to-research-articles-slow-down-research lists and details some of its negative effects, which are quite obvious anyway. How comes public research's results are not public as well? This blows my mind.
As a side note there is a society for open science at MIT. Ping me if you want more information or to become a member: francky at mit dot edu. (no ad intended, just trying to continue his work)
RIP Aaron.
Investigate this because,most probably, has been suicided.
by cory docktorow
too many here are sounding like wackos...
leave that to the gun nuts...
We all know that the powers-that-be are looking for excuses to get people like Aaron. Institutions need to stand up against them.
I am thinking about myself, and what would have happened if I had killed myself.
I am remembering that at the time, it seemed like the only thing to do, the best thing to do.
Well. I don't know you. Didn't know of you until an hour ago.
I use Reddit a lot. I get to read the news about everything and pick fights with stupid people so I can feel better about myself.
Right now, I want to tell you not to worry. That I know you are aware of people like me - that you're preparing the work you must do.
Go to your mother and father and brothers and sisters. Tell them not to be angry. Tell them they are not to blame. Let them know that you are alright.
Endeavour to make practical differences in their lives. Remember that on Earth, money can make a practical difference.
A deferred court ruling. The absolution of financial debt.
I am sad right now, over someone I did not know...but I think I understand, I really do.
Don't be frightened by the light shining through, don't be disturbed by the choice you made.
From someone who did not know you - be free now. And act.
Tell my sister that I love her.
kreemer
Aaron: the flower is,
the sun shines,
you are naturally eternal bliss consciousness, being.
Namaste.
Please investigate this young man's death.
I say shame on MIT for their behavior here as well. MIT of all places should realize that Aaron was the last person that deserved prosecution. Time for MIT's general counsel to admit mea maxima culpa.
But, when a person is stuck in the depth of depression: all realistic relief SEEMS impossible to obtain.
That's where we -the observer- need to intervene: just as we would when we see a child running into the street.
http://www.samaritans.org/media-centre/media-guidelines/reporting-suicide-tips-journalists
My sincere sympathies and empathy to the family and friends. Aaron's pain is now placed with the family to try and make sense of and live with for the rest of their lives. My heart goes to his Momma and his family - hugs.
Leslie
The Surviving Project
Either robs this young man of his agency. Please respect his dignity even in death.
And if you insist on a larger message let it be this: mental illness can be a terminal disease, and it is a potential threat to all of us.
Authorities in New York have notoriously undertaken a similar assault on Internet freedom, arresting and prosecuting a blogger who sent out Gmail confessions (written in a deadpan, yet sharply humorous tone) in which a New York University department chairman appeared to be accusing himself of plagiarism. What impact will this case have on the life of the author of these satirical writings and his family? For further information on the case, see:
http://raphaelgolbtrial.wordpress.com/
It is ridiculous that MIT worked with the federal government to go so far with this prosecution of a victimless crime. If MIT is embarrassed about having such an open network that this deed could be easily accomplished, work on your own security system, don't threaten an intelligent young man with decades of imprisonment.
Geez, I don't know how MIT's legal team can sleep at night. It's absolutely disgraceful and goes against the principle that scientific knowledge should be made available to the public.
the Beatles sing "Don't carry the world upon your shoulder" . . . Aaron, life you haven't understood, you would have understood it would you have recognized, "the way is the aim".
Bits and bytes are even much fewer the live. You have much "unfinished" left, for a Beethoven, however, you are far too young why I can't recognize either that your life circulation was perfect.
Last but not least, if already self killing, then but for mankind. How it would be landmines clear up in Afghanistan?! The girls collecting wood for a fire being warm and for boiling, I mean those, which ones stood in the middle of life, had been grateful for you certainly.
Schutzritter (52), Good Old Germany.
They were asking for 30 years in jail for actions equivalent to handcuffing yourself to a shelf in the library.
Letter from Aaron Swartz' family: http://rememberaaronsw.tumblr.com/post/40372208044/official-statement-from-the-family-and-partner-of-aaron
We need to support his ideas for a better world. I just joined sumofus.org And contributed to demandprogress.org
There will never be a trial now to determine his guilt under the law, but downloading 5 million copyrighted documents that you dont own from a university that you dont attend with the intention of making them public has got to be some sort of crime.
Would Aaron have really been sentenced to 35 years in jail? No way. But thats how the game (which as I said before, Aaron knowingly chose to play) is played the prosecutor wildly overcharges you, your lawyers claim that you havent committed any crime at all and you end up somewhere in between. The Feds usual goal is to get you to plead guilty to some lesser offense. Apparently Aaron refused to plead guilty to ANY felony and so the Feds pressed on with their case. This goes on every day of the week in every state and the defendants dont kill themselves.
I don't know much about him, but I know many people who were considered brilliant and were looked up to by many people who seriously contemplated suicide for various reasons. You can be strong-willed and still become depressed; it's not like it's controllable. To say that he simply "could not" have committed suicide demonstrates a vast misunderstanding of mental health. You can't be inside someone's mind and understand, especially if you've never been in that place before. What happened is tragic, but not unbelievable.
RIP
S
Remove United States District Attorney Carmen Ortiz from office for overreach in the case of Aaron Swartz
https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/remove-united-states-district-attorney-carmen-ortiz-office-overreach-case-aaron-swartz/RQNrG1Ck
Continue his fight:
http://powned.dk
What Aaron did is not so different from what I do all the time at MIT as an independent scholar at Hayden Library. Many of the subscription resources on campus are available to visitors as long as their laptops are on the campus wireless. What Aaron did was just hit Save-As a lot.
Just about every instructor in every two-bit community college does the same thing, without clearing copywrite, well beyond the limits of fair use, for copying whole papers and book chapters for class handouts. But no one prosecutes them or threatens to send them to jail for three decades.
Aaron is a modern Galileo, giving the finger to the modern established church. Galileo was put away for defying an order to not publish, not for his heliocentrism. The church didn't hesitate to burn heretics like Giordano Bruno in the public square -- they didn't disagree that the earth orbits the sun. But they'd asked Galileo not to publish his book because a rising literate intellectual class would cause issues of damage control questioning the dissonance between biblical and scientific authority. So the church put on a show trial and locked the scientist away on house arrest -- they couldn't let him win.
Aaron couldn't be allowed to win, and had probably come to realize it. The very reasons he thought he couldn't lose -- the power of his reach in social networking that allowed him to direct efforts like the SOPA/PIPA fight -- had painted him into a corner. The pitbulls had been called out.
It's possible MIT Legal hanging him out to dry was the last straw. I may show up Tuesday (I'm former staff, btw) with a sign that says "Who killed Aaron Swartz?" until I can get some answers.
Because academic politics is bad enough without being fatal. What a colossal waste.
Aaron's family is blaming us. I am ashamed.
http://rememberaaronsw.tumblr.com/post/40372208044/official-statement-from-the-family-and-partner-of-aaron
I only hope that all the other smart and visionary information age doers and thinkers will find another university to cooperate with.
We cannot really afford to lose people with that kind of competence and vision; please don't kill off any more of them. (Putting him in jail would have had the same effect - there's no point arguing that it isn't a capital punishment.)
Aaron Swartz took his own life. That's bad enough.
http://rememberaaronsw.tumblr.com/post/40372208044/official-statement-from-the-family-and-partner-of-aaron
Rest in peace, Aaron.
and all the morons on other sites chastising this kid, dont realize some of the code that makes comment sections work, was part of aarons, rss work. this government has run amok.
Not that any explanation will justify their actions, but still.
Wouldn't an even halfway sensible person cut and run after being discovered, not return and escalate the level of intrusion?
Aaron's crime was not harmless. Besides the betrayal of the academic community, MIT pays $830,000 a year for access to JSTOR. Divided over 261 business days a year, that's $3180 a day. MIT's being disconnected from JSTOR represented a five-figure loss to MIT and/or JSTOR.
Mourn his passing if you must but don't hold him up as an exemplar of anything. He was merely a talented programmer who failed to gain the maturity usually concomitant with progress.
https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/remove-united-states-district-attorney-carmen-ortiz-office-overreach-case-aaron-swartz/RQNrG1Ck
"He's young and idealistic. In time he will be mature enough to put his talents to better uses. The cyber threat from hostile countries is growing and we could use people like him."
Looking for a Few Good Men, Comment to "Swartz Indicted for JSTOR Theft," Tech (Aug. 25, 2011).
"The trail of his brief life shines with his brilliant creativity and idealism....
"I want to express very clearly that I [am] extremely saddened by the death of this promising young man .... It pains me to think that MIT played any role in [this] series of events ...."
Posting of Rafael Reif to MIT Cmty. (Jan. 13, 2013).
Chronology
Reed elected Chairman: June 4, 2010
Swartz charged with wire fraud: July 14, 2011
Reif appointed President: May 2, 2012
Dervorguilla of Wikipedia
MtE '87
If she ever runs for anything, I will follow her around with a sign reading "CARMEN ORTIZ - WANTED FOR MURDER." I know many from the Boston-Cambridge academic communities who have said they will do likewise, along with others who have pledged to come over from Cornell, and from as far west as Stanford and Berkeley.
Rest in peace Aaron. We will carry on this cause.
I'm an MIT graduate also and I think that gave me courage to stand up to DOJ.
Another prosecutor chose not to bring charges against Swartz when hew broke the law and opened up a government site.
In the words of P. Sainath, India's leading journalistic voice, "This was not suicide. It was murder by intimidation, bullying, and torment."
It is truly amazing how many people now believe breaking the law is acceptable on the grounds that you personally do not agree with the law. What a sad commentary on todays youth.
As to your comment on Ortiz, liberals tend to shy away from anything related to personal responsibility. Do you believe that when someone commits a socially unacceptable action, it is always someone else's fault?
And there is a good alternative available -- bundling publication with total research/scholarship cost. Less than one percent of most projects' cost including overhead could easily support free online publication available to everyone (including scholars at non-rich universities).
Nothing better illustrates the misuse of intellectual property to impose an economy of scarcity on a newly available possibility of abundance.
https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/appoint-independent-investigator-subpoena-power-investigate-instances-doj-bullying-extorsion-and/ZrDymCLq
Just hope that you would have stay longer in life to fight for free ACCESS to sciencific articles and free public information.
I am from developing country that paying for public articles are a pain in my pocket and stomach.
Damn the Capitalist.
